Well, yes, they are supposed to be. If you WANT pointy feet get them, otherwise they will be too pointy for me.

They are pointy, and that's why I bought them. Every other oxford I have been looking at has a round toe, and I think the point gives it a modern update. I know, however, that a lot of people have adverse feelings towards pointy shoes, and if so, these are probably not for you.

Yes they are pointy but I think the fact they are so cute makes it not matter to me. It really depends on the person's opinion of it...

I got mine yesterday and have been wearing them all day now. I usually wear 4" heels in the winter, so these are quite comfortable in comparison. Depending on the footwear you are used to, the point may take some getting used to as it extends past your actual toes. There are no "sore spots", which was surprising as they are a somewhat rigid material.

Womens, and they are true to size (maybe run a BIT large). I am normally an 8, bought an 8 and am wearing them with crew socks comfortably.

Leather thin black laces

No they are more of a vibrant green than the forest in the photos.

... what store typically charges you per shoe?

You're paying $58 for the pair.